“Big Bailouts” by % of GDP
Some friends sent me this blog post, which shows how the current planned bailout exceeds the combined expenditure of a number of government spending events from the history of our nation. That post uses the current cost of the bailout ($4.616 trillion), which some friends have noted is closer to $7.6 trillion if one includes unspent guarantees.
These numbers are inflation adjusted, but I was still curious to see how they stacked up in terms of national GDP at their time. I wanted to know how big each event was in proportion to what our nation was producing, since this number has grown dramatically over the last century.
The figures aren’t really apples-to-apples comparisons, since all of these expenditures were multi-year affairs. Having each of them broken into expenditures per year would yield some neat %-of-GDP graphs (different bumps for each item, % of GDP on the y-axis, years on the x-axis; volume representing the total cost of an expenditure.)
In any case, here are the non-matched-fruit comparisons. As you can see, the bailout is still truly massive, on par with (but lower than) the New Deal and WWII (which I added):
| Spending | Cost | Cost (Inflation-Adj.) | %GDP (Year) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marshall Plan | $12.7 billion | $115.3 billion | 5.20% (1947) |
| Louisiana Purchase | $15 million | $217 billion | unavailable |
| Race to the Moon | $36.4 billion | $237 billion | 3.70% (1969) |
| S&L Crisis | $153 billion | $256 billion | 2.79% (1989) |
| Korean War | $54 billion | $454 billion | 14.23% (1953) |
| The New Deal | $32 billion | $500 billion | 56.74% (1933) |
| Invasion of Iraq | $551 billion | $597 billion | 5.03% (2003) |
| Vietnam War | $111 billion | $698 billion | 6.78% (1975) |
| NASA | $416.7 billion | $851.2 billion | 3.02% (2007) |
| WWII | $288 billion | $3,290 billion | 129.09% (1945) |
| 2008 Credit Crisis Bailout | $4,616 billion | $4,616 billion | 32.65% (2008) |
The spreadsheet is here.
Note: WWII cost figure from the National D-Day Museum
Related Posts:
- Downward Spiral (October, 2008)
- Toyota Kicking Some Major Ass (February, 2006)
- The Money Man’s Burden (September, 2006)
- Uprooting Nationalism (October, 2005)
- WattzOn: Personal Energy Profile (December, 2008)

December 1st, 2008 at 2:02 pm
[...] good friend Nagu has a great post comparing the current government bailout of banks to previous large-scale government expenditures. His post [...]
December 3rd, 2008 at 7:41 am
[...] via mindtangle [...]
December 3rd, 2008 at 8:54 am
[...] chart courtesy of mindtangle [...]
December 4th, 2008 at 9:36 am
[...] cifras que encuentro sobre la magnitud de la actual crisis y los planes de rescate. En primer lugar doy con un cuadro que compara los actuales fondos del gobierno destinados a combatir la crisis actual con crisis [...]
December 7th, 2008 at 11:27 am
[...] mindtangle (note that this data is already [...]
December 8th, 2008 at 10:45 am
[...] el presupuesto de la NASA corresponde a un periodo que va desde los años cuarenta hasta hoy. Algunos han optado por tomar una fecha central como [...]
January 30th, 2009 at 2:14 pm
I wonder where the “2009″ bailout will rank in this table.